What's the Difference: Impact Crusher vs Jaw Crusher

Home
Blog
Equipment Info
Impact Crusher vs Jaw Crusher: What’s the Difference?

Picking the right crusher is key, no matter if you work in mining, construction, or recycling. The impact crusher and jaw crusher are two popular machines, each known for its specific strengths and uses. What sets them apart is how they crush materials, the type of stuff they handle, and the size of the products they produce. This piece dives into what makes impact crushers and jaw crushers different, looking closely at their characteristics, benefits, and ideal uses. Knowing how they vary will help you choose the best one for your project.

Basic Steps in the Crushing Process

The journey of turning large rocks into smaller aggregates or even sand involves a meticulous and systematic process. Let’s break down this process step by step, highlighting the role of different crushers and providing concrete data to better understand the transformation of raw materials into the final product.

Selection and Preparation of Raw Material

The process begins with the careful selection and preparation of the raw material. Typically, this involves quarrying large boulders or extracting them from natural deposits, ranging in size from several feet across (usually up to 4-6 feet in diameter) to smaller gravel-sized pieces. The composition can vary widely, from hard granite or basalt to softer limestone or sandstone.

Primary Crushing

Primary crushing is the first reduction stage and aims to reduce the raw material to a manageable size for further processing. A Jaw Crusher is predominantly used at this stage due to its capability to handle large and hard materials. A typical jaw crusher can accept boulders that are about 75-90% of the size of its gape (the distance between the jaws at the feed opening), which, for large crushers, can be up to 48 inches wide. Through the use of compressive force, the Jaw Crusher reduces these large boulders into pieces roughly 6 to 8 inches in size.

Secondary Crushing

After the initial breakdown, materials are then passed to secondary crushers to further reduce their size. Typically, this stage utilizes Cone Crushers or Horizontal Shaft Impactors (HSI). A Cone Crusher works by compressing the material between a gyrating cone and a stationary outer casing, achieving size reductions to about 0.5 to 3 inches, ideally suited for further processing. On the other hand, HSIs are used for somewhat softer materials, projecting the aggregate against hard surfaces to achieve size reduction, usually to about 2 inches or less.

Tertiary Crushing and Finishing Processes

Some operations may require further refinement of the material; this is where Tertiary Crushers like Vertical Shaft Impactors (VSI) come into play, specializing in producing very fine materials such as sand, ranging from 1/4 to 3/8 inch in size. VSIs employ high-speed rotors and wear-resistant tips that shatter the rock upon impact, creating particles of a consistent shape and size.

After tertiary crushing, the material often goes through additional processes such as screening (to sort the material by size), washing (to remove unwanted particles or chemicals), and sometimes even further reduction stages, depending on the specific requirements of the final product.

From Boulders to Sand: The Overall Picture

Summing up, the crushing process typically involves:

At each stage, the size reduction serves the practical purposes of handling, transportation, and suitability for the intended final application, be it construction, landscaping, asphalt, or concrete production. This detailed walk-through outlines how raw, untouched material undergoes transformation through the orchestrated action of various types of crushers, each playing a specific role in producing aggregates of desired sizes and shapes.

Types and Roles of Crushing Machines

Crusher Type	Crushing Stage	Processed Mineral Types	Input Material Size	Output Material Size	Other Key Features
Jaw Crusher	Primary	Gold, Copper, Limestone	Up to 1200mm (48 inches)	150mm-300mm (6-12 inches)	High durability, suitable for hard materials
Impact Crusher	Secondary	Limestone, Asphalt, Gravel	Not exceeding 800mm (31 inches)	Var. down to 25mm (1 inch)	High reduction ratio, good for soft to medium-hard materials
Cone Crusher	Secondary/Tertiary	Gold, Copper, Silver	Up to 300mm (12 inches)	20mm-50mm (0.75-2 inches)	Precise control over output size, suitable for medium-hard materials
Vertical Shaft Impactors (VSI)	Tertiary/Quaternary	Sand, Gravel	Up to 50mm (2 inches)	1mm-5mm (0.04-0.2 inches)	Produces fine particles, good for producing sand-like textures
Gyratory Crusher	Primary/Secondary	Iron, Gold, Copper	Up to 2000mm (79 inches)	100mm-200mm (4-8 inches)	Handles large volumes, high throughput
Roll Crushers	Secondary/Tertiary	Coal, Limestone, Potash	Not exceeding 80mm (3 inches)	2mm-10mm (0.08-0.4 inches)	Low fine production, suitable for friable materials
Hammer Crusher	Secondary, Tertiary	Limestone, Gypsum, Coal	Up to 600mm (24 inches)	15mm-50mm (0.6-2 inches)	High reduction ratio, suitable for brittle materials

What is an Impact Crusher?

Design Principle and Operating Method

Impact crushers operate on a dynamic principle where the material to be crushed is fed into a chamber containing a high-speed rotor. This rotor is equipped with a series of hammers or blow bars that spin at speeds reaching 50-60,000 revolutions per minute. As the material enters the chamber, the rapidly rotating hammers catch and accelerate it outward, where it is hurled against impact plates or anvils lining the chamber walls. This process subjects the material to high levels of stress at points of natural weakness, causing it to fracture along its fault lines.

The unique features of an impact crusher consist of:

Rotor: Consider the rotor the core of the impact crusher-it's where the hammers reside. This component is designed to withstand various loads and speeds, ensuring a smooth operation throughout.
Hammers/Blow Bars: Attached to the rotor, these elements are made from incredibly strong high manganese steel or similarly durable alloys. Their primary role? To hit the incoming pieces and fragment them.
Impact Plates/Anvils: Positioned within the crushing area, these provide a sturdy platform against which the material is shattered.
Feed Inlet: This is where the material starts its journey. The design of the feed inlet is vital for regulating how much material enters the crusher and preventing any jams.
Discharge Opening: This feature controls the size of the output material from the crusher, and can be adjusted to meet the needs of different projects.

Operating Methods

Impact crushers are categorized into two main types based on their operating methods:

Horizontal Shaft Impactors (HSI): Ideal for softer to medium-hard materials, HSIs offer excellent control over particle shape. They are frequently used for limestone or materials with lower abrasiveness.
Vertical Shaft Impactors (VSI): Best suited for harder materials like granite and basalt, VSIs focus on producing high-quality sand and aggregates with a cubic shape. They operate by throwing material against stationary anvils using centrifugal force.

Key Features of Impact Crushers

The key features of impact crushers are enhanced by real-world performance metrics and examples. For instance:

High Reduction Ratios: Take a typical HSI, for example, it can knock down the size of stuff we're working with by a whopping 20 times. And get this - some VSIs go even further, shrinking things down by up to 50 times depending on what you're breaking up. Imagine taking something as big as 500mm across and squishing it down to just 25mm in one go.
Production Capacity: When it comes to getting a lot done fast, modern impact crushers are real powerhouses. Let’s say you’ve got a mid-sized HSI that’s about 1 meter wide at its mouth - it can crunch through more than 500 tons of limestone or stuff like that in just one hour.
Versatility and Product Quality: One significant advantage is the ability to produce uniform, cubical-shaped particles, which is paramount for the concrete and asphalt industry. The cubic shape ensures higher compressive strength and durability for the final product.
Energy Efficiency: Impact crushers are also known for their energy efficiency. The method of using kinetic energy from the high-speed rotor to break down materials minimizes power consumption while maximizing output.

What is a Jaw Crusher?

Design Principle and Operating Method

At its heart, a jaw crusher is all about strength and its ability to break down big chunks of material. It’s made up of two main parts: a stationary jaw and a moving one, often called the swing jaw. The swing jaw is attached to a sturdy steel shaft that spins around. As it moves back and forth, it squishes the material against the fixed jaw, smashing it.

The part of the crusher where the magic really happens is specially shaped in a V. This V shape is super important because it makes sure that the crushing is done super efficiently. How big or small the crushed material ends up being depends on the gap at the bottom of the V, which can be adjusted.

When you start using a jaw crusher, you feed the machine with big pieces of material from the top. These big pieces then break down bit by bit between the two jaws. The material keeps getting squished until it’s small enough to fall out through the gap at the bottom.

For a detailed explanation of the process, view Simple Guide: How Does a Jaw Crusher Work?

Key Features of Jaw Crushers

High Crushing Capacity and Size Reduction: One of the standout features of jaw crushers is their strong ability to handle incredibly large feed sizes. Some models can even process giant boulders up to one cubic meter in size. They also have a high reduction ratio of up to 8:1, meaning they can significantly reduce material size in just one go.
Flexibility in Output Size: The closed side setting (CSS) of a jaw crusher, which is key to determining the size of the end product, can be adjusted. This flexibility lets you change the output size to meet various crushing needs, from breaking down big rocks to creating finely crushed stone. This makes jaw crushers incredibly versatile for various tasks.
High Processing Ability: High-capacity jaw crushers can crush up to 5000 tons of material per hour, making them perfect for large-scale mining and quarrying jobs. For example, in a large-scale copper mine, a jaw crusher plays a crucial role in breaking down huge chunks of ore before they're further processed in grinding mills.
Built to Last: Jaw crushers are made to withstand harsh working environments, thanks to their heavy-duty construction and high-quality materials. Their strong design includes a hefty frame and a large flywheel, boosting their efficiency.
Wide Range of Applications: Jaw crushers are not just for mining and making aggregates; they're also great for recycling. For instance, they can turn old concrete from demolition sites into usable gravel. This shows how adaptable they are.
Energy-Saving Design: Despite their size, modern jaw crushers are designed to be energy-efficient. Many models come with tech improvements that lower energy use, cutting down on running costs. This focus on better energy management helps reduce the costs of operations.

Comparison Table of the Two Crusher Types

Feature	Impact Crusher	Jaw Crusher
Principle	High-speed impact	Compression
Material Type	More suited for medium to soft	Best for hard materials
Final Product	Cubical and uniform	Varied sizes tend to be larger pieces
Reduction Ratio	High	Moderate to high
Maintenance	Less frequent but higher skill required	More frequent but simpler
Application	Secondary/tertiary crushing, recycling	Primary crushing, mining, aggregate

Suitability and Advantages of Jaw Crushers

Jaw crushers are robust, heavy-duty machines designed to efficiently crush hard materials such as granite, basalt, limestone, iron ore, and copper ore. These crushers are particularly effective in primary crushing applications for materials that are not only hard but also large and abrasive, making them invaluable in mining and quarry operations. Here’s a closer look at the types of rocks and minerals most suitable for processing with jaw crushers:

Most Suitable Types of Rocks/Minerals

● Granite

Granite stands out for its hardness and abrasiveness, qualities that demand a powerful and durable crusher. Jaw crushers are up to the task, capable of breaking down large chunks of granite into manageable sizes for further processing or direct use in construction.

● Basalt

Like granite, basalt is known for its hardness and durability. It is another common material for jaw crushers to process, often used in road and railway construction after being crushed due to its excellent performance in creating strong, dense aggregates.

● Limestone

Though limestone is comparatively softer than granite and basalt, it is a popular choice for cement production and various construction purposes. Jaw crushers easily handle limestone, breaking it down into sizes suitable for the market.

● Iron Ore

At the beginning of extracting iron ore, big chunks of the ore are first broken down by using jaw crushers. This crucial step significantly makes the iron ore smaller, making the next steps easier, which involve grinding and cleaning it up. These parts of the process are vital for getting the iron ore ready for the market, making sure it meets the right standards for both quality and cleanliness.

● Copper Ore

Kicking off the process of getting copper ore out of the ground begins with using jaw crushers to break down the big chunks into smaller bits. This step is super important because it makes it a lot easier to get to the copper using methods like flotation and leaching later on. By breaking the ore into finer pieces first, we can get more copper out of the ore, making the whole process of turning it into something we can sell much smoother.

Crushing Fineness and Capacity

Jaw crushers aren’t just great at munching through hard rock. They’re pretty handy with softer stuff too, offering a range of options for different jobs. Whether you need tiny bits of gravel for laying roads or bits of aggregate for making concrete, these crushers can get it down to as small as 3/4 inches. Need to handle a mountain of material? No problem. Jaw crushers can tackle between 1300 to 1500 tons every single hour, making them a go-to for heavy-duty tasks in mining or quarrying.

Suitability and Advantages of Impact Crushers

Impact crushers are real game-changers in industries like mining, construction, and recycling due to their top-notch efficiency and flexibility. They can handle both medium and fine crushing jobs, streamlining the entire crushing process. This makes them indispensable in churning out superior quality aggregate materials.

Most Suitable Types of Rocks/Minerals

Impact crushers are champs when it comes to softer rocks and minerals. They have a knack for smashing limestone, gypsum, calcite, and a bunch of others into tinier bits very effectively. But that’s not all they’re good at. Here’s the scoop on some of the best materials they deal with:

● Limestone and Gypsum
These are a dream team for impact crushers because they break easily. This means the crusher can make pieces that are all about the same size, which is awesome if you need to do more with the material later on.

● Calcite and Dolomite
Since these minerals are on the softer side, the gentle whack from the impact crusher works wonders. You end up with finely crushed stuff without beating up the machine too much.

● Asphalt and Concrete Recycling
Got old roads or buildings that need new life? Impact crushers are perfect for this job. Their powerful smacks break down these tough materials into smaller bits that you can use again, which is super efficient.

● Making Stuff for Roads
One cool thing about impact crushers is that they make everything pretty uniform, which is exactly what you want when you’re building roads.

Crushing Fineness and Capacity

One cool thing about impact crushers is how they can get the job done, no matter how fine or coarse you want your outcome to be. For instance, a regular-sized impact crusher can handle as much as 500 tons every single hour, as long as the stuff you’re crushing plays along. With the ability to tweak the settings, you can get anything from chunky bits to super fine grains. This means impact crushers can take on all sorts of jobs across different industries.

Key Factors in Crusher Selection

Choosing the right crusher, whether it’s an impact crusher or a jaw crusher, is crucial for your project. Knowing what to consider can not only help you save money but also guarantee that your project goes off without a hitch. Let’s explore the key points that should guide your decision:

1. Material Characteristics

● Toughness and Roughness: Typically, jaw crushers are the go-to for breaking down tough, gritty stuff like granite or basalt. On the flip side, impact crushers shine when it comes to materials that aren’t as hard and are less gritty, such as limestone.

● Material Size: When it comes to big chunks of rock, jaw crushers really show their strength. They’re perfect for the first step of breaking things down. Impact crushers, though, take the lead with smaller, softer bits of material.

2. Desired Product Size

● Output Size Requirements: If your project needs a certain size of particles, especially the smaller ones, going for an impact crusher might be the smart move. This choice makes sense because impact crushers are great at making uniform, tiny sizes. On the flip side, if you’re okay with a mix of sizes, including some bigger chunks, a jaw crusher could do the trick.

3. Production Capacity

● Throughput Needs: High-volume projects might benefit more from jaw crushers, which can process large amounts of material quickly. Impact crushers, while efficient, may have a lower capacity for large volumes but provide precision in the final product’s size and shape.

4. Operation Costs and Efficiency

● Energy Consumption: Assess the energy efficiency of the equipment, as this will directly impact operational costs. Impact crushers may offer better energy efficiency for medium-hardness materials.

● Maintenance and Wear Parts: Consider the maintenance needs and durability of wear parts. Jaw crushers may require less frequent but potentially more intensive maintenance than impact crushers, which might have higher wear part costs due to the nature of their operation.

5. Project Goals and End Use

● Specific Project Needs: The choice might also depend on the specific goals of your project. For example, if making aggregate for road construction is the aim, the grain shape and size uniformity from an impact crusher might be preferable.

● Secondary Processing: Consider whether the crushed material will undergo further processing. If additional crushing stages are anticipated, the initial crushing phase might prefer a jaw crusher for creating larger chunks conducive to secondary crushing.

6. Installation Space and Mobility

● Space Limits: The crusher’s size and ability to move could be key, especially when space is tight or hard to get to. Portable impact crushers are great because they’re easy to move around a site or from place to place.

● Fitting in With What’s Already There: The way the crusher fits into your current setup could sway your decision, looking for an easy integration and little to no hassle.

Operation and Maintenance

Keeping your crushing machines running smoothly and for a long time is key to getting the most out of your operations. When it comes to impact crushers, you won’t need to roll up your sleeves as often, but it’s still pretty important to know what needs checking and changing. Since these machines work fast and hard, parts like the hammers – which do the heavy lifting of bashing the material – and the plates where the magic happens wear out and need swapping from time to time. Make sure you’re keeping an eye on these bits, along with the parts that make them spin.

On the flip side, jaw crushers need you to check in more often, but it’s a bit simpler to keep them happy. You’ve got to watch how the crushing plates are holding up and keep everything greased up right. Also, tweaking the settings now and then is crucial to make sure you’re crushing rocks (or whatever you’ve got) to the size you need.

Sticking to these pointers not only makes your crushers last longer and work better, but also keeps your whole operation humming along smoothly.

Conclusion

Wrapping it up, when you’re weighing your options between an impact crusher and a jaw crusher, it’s pretty obvious that each has its best fit for certain tasks. Your decision really hinges on what your project demands are, what kind of materials you’re working with, and what you want your final product to look like. Getting a handle on these distinctions is crucial for making your crushing process as efficient as it can be and for getting top-notch outcomes. Just keep in mind, choosing the perfect match for your needs is what will really make or break your project’s success!For successful project outcomes, consider Top 8 Jaw Crusher Manufacturers to Power Up Your Project .

Company

Basic Steps in the Crushing Process

Selection and Preparation of Raw Material

Primary Crushing

Secondary Crushing

Tertiary Crushing and Finishing Processes

From Boulders to Sand: The Overall Picture

Types and Roles of Crushing Machines

What is an Impact Crusher?

Design Principle and Operating Method

Key Features of Impact Crushers

What is a Jaw Crusher?

Design Principle and Operating Method

Key Features of Jaw Crushers

Comparison Table of the Two Crusher Types

Suitability and Advantages of Jaw Crushers

Most Suitable Types of Rocks/Minerals

Crushing Fineness and Capacity

Suitability and Advantages of Impact Crushers

Most Suitable Types of Rocks/Minerals

Crushing Fineness and Capacity

Key Factors in Crusher Selection

Operation and Maintenance

Conclusion

Share:

Related Posts

Contact Your Personal Mineral Experts

37+

Years of Experience

500+

Satisfied Clients

1,000+

Successful Plant Projects

40+

Mineral Solutions

40+

Serving Countries & Regions

Get In Touch with us

Equipment

Expertise

About

Media

search Products

Speak to Our Experts Today

Contact Us